Social Media trumps the personal website

two-roads

Image from Tool Shed Meditation (WordPress blog)

A few years ago I decided to set up a professional website on which I could share content such as my resume and other information; I later transitioned that site to a personal one in which I could share photos, write more casual blogs, and track concerts that I had attended. When I first created it, I registered a domain (geoffirwin.com) and obtained hosting services (where the website files are stored) through GoDaddy. Then, I used Apple’s iWeb product to create the pages.

While the site fit what I was looking for at the time, it is now outdated and no longer meets my needs. For example, it is not optimized for mobile devices or social media sharing, and I would be better off using the space for professional content. In considering redeveloping the site to take advantage of mobility and social media, and to develop a greater professional branding location, I have found myself asking a simple question: is it worth developing a new site, or should I spend more time taking advantage of LinkedIn’s features?

How does LinkedIn meet my needs?
LinkedIn content can be accessed via desktop and mobile devices, and because it is an integrated social media platform, blogs that are created on it are automatically shared with the blogger’s network. Other LinkedIn users can easily interact with those blogs and do not have to enter additional contact information (like an email address) in order to participate. LinkedIn also now allows sharing of work examples such as PDF and Word Documents, images, and videos. All of this functionality is free, with the option to upgrade, and without the concern of technical site administration. This solution meets most of my ideals for a professional online presence.

LinkedIn does not meet all of my ideals, however. While users can see who is viewing their profile, they do not have a detailed breakdown or summarization of who is viewing their blogs—only a number of views and any impressions that the blog receives. This means that it will be more difficult to determine whether my blogs are reaching their target. I have also found that LinkedIn blogs are not as easily found through Google searches versus posts on WordPress, which could limit the audience it is viewed by.

What will I get by creating and hosting my own site?
I have a subscription to services on GoDaddy, and until recently I did not realize how much that subscription actually had to offer. GoDaddy’s hosting service provides access to over 40 applications that can be integrated into a website, or used to develop one. There are multiple photo galleries; blog engines; content management solutions; ecommerce solutions; wikis and bulletin boards; and other applications. Using a combination of these tools provides individuals and organizations with much more branding control and more opportunities to customize the user experience. A personal website can also act as a central place to direct social media traffic from multiple networks when using a multi-network strategy. Lastly, it allows content owners to take advantage of Google Analytics in order to gain insights into who is viewing their content, how long they are spending on it, and how they are getting to it.

Of course, there are also downsides to hosting a site, as well including cost and time requirements for hosting, developing, and maintaining the site. This is true even when GoDaddy, and other sites like Wix, have tools that make it easy to create the site. Maintaining a blog on a personal site also may lead to more requirements to promote that blog through social media.

When I started looking into this, I asked a simple question: is it worth maintaining my own site? If I were running a business (ex. a professional photographer) or had a multi-social network strategy, maintaining a website might make sense. In that situation, I could move from GoDaddy to Wix, which is cheaper and has pre-developed HTML5 templates (suitable for mobile devices). However, I don’t have those needs right now, and given that LinkedIn meets most of my needs, and has tremendous recruiting and professional development potential, I do not foresee the need for a multi-network strategy right now. This may change in the future, but for now, social media trumps the personal website.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Apps, Case Studies, Google, Human Resources, LinkedIn, Metrics, Social Media, Strategy, User Generated Content and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Social Media trumps the personal website

  1. sydhavely says:

    First rate post,Geoff. Insightful as well as descriptive in pointing up LinkedIn’s advantages over GoDaddy. I happen to love the photo of your website. It’s just so calming. I’d like to be standing there. Indeed, it’s meditative in tone, color, and image.

  2. Geoff Irwin says:

    Thanks!
    I can’t take credit for the photo I used for the blog. I was looking for one that I took that said, “Two roads diverge in a wood,” but didn’t find one. I aspire to take pictures like the one I used. If you go to http://www.geoffirwin.com, there’s a few links at the top that lead to my photos. One of my favorites on my site is address below, but I haven’t updated with the pictures I took in Korea, which I think are much better.

    http://www.geoffirwin.com/me/Life.html#5

  3. Adam Preset says:

    Nice post, Geoff.

    I’ve had some similar thoughts and done some experimentation over the years: personal outlets on standalone websites/Facebook/YouTube/WordPress/Blogger, professional on LinkedIn, blend of both on Google+/Twitter/About.me/RebelMouse. I like omnichannel approaches for creativity, but have failed a couple times on execution with aggregating everything back in one place. I think I rationalize this by saying that different audiences expect different things, and not with an excuse like one single site not being able to contain my multitudes.

    It’s a lot of work and curation to pull everything back together. I might reinvestigate this soon, though, as I hope to do more formal lifelogging and having a single place to look at my personal timeline, personal and professional, would be interesting. Whether I would have it public is another question.

    • Geoff Irwin says:

      Thanks so much for the comment, Adam.
      I would agree that the omnichannel approach is probably the way to reach the largest number of people. I wrote the blog with a focus on my professional brand, and there’s a question of how much time I should (or want to) spend managing that. This is a big part of why I’m likely pursuing a LinkedIn only professional strategy for now. I’ve started to think about my photographic hobby more, and whether I’d like to share that along with reflective blogs. The question becomes whether I’d have a broader goal for that blog than personal reflection, such as sharing ideas that others would connect with and drawing readers into that blog.

      Your question of whether to do lifelogging publicly or not is a really challenging one for me. On one hand, I like being open and sharing about myself. On the other hand, there are boundaries to what I would write to keep a certain level of privacy. The other part of this is how much of my identity to put out there. I may not write everything, but you could certainly piece together a lot of a person’s writings and detect themes/patterns that may not otherwise be visible. I read an article recently where IBM Watson was fed the Harry Potter books and movie scripts and identified the differences in themes and underlying stories. Certainly this is also possible with blog content, and this leaves a question in mind of whether putting too much of ones self out there is an identity theft risk.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s